Matthew 25:14-30
November 15, 2026
When I was a junior in high school,
I ran for student body secretary, an office I would have held in my senior
year. I no longer remember why I wanted to run, but I must have thought I would
be good at it. I had never run for any kind of class position like that before.
I had never before had some burning ambition to be a class officer. But I
decided to put myself out there and run. I came up with campaign slogans. My
friends and I made buttons and handed them out during lunch hour and between
classes. I wrote a speech with the help of an older student. I gave the speech.
I got really excited about all of it. I lost.
I was heartbroken, even though I
tried to pretend that I wasn’t. But I was. A teacher talked to me about it,
trying to comfort me. And in the course of trying to comfort me said something
about “the next time,” as in the next time you run for something. And while my
memory is fuzzy about many things, I do remember this. I said, “there will
never be a next time. I will never run for office again.” And I didn’t.
Later in college, I served in
leadership of different groups. I was editor of a school creative writing
publication. In seminary, I was president of a campus group. As a minister, I
have served in leadership in different committees. I was vice-moderator and
moderator of the John Knox Presbytery. But I have only served in those
capacities because I was asked. When I still lived in Iowa, I was talking with
a town council person about some issues in the community. We talked for a few
minutes, then she stopped and looked at me and said, “Have you ever thought
about running for local office? We really need people like you to be in
leadership roles.”
My response was immediate and
definitive. “Nope. No way. Not going to consider it, nor will I ever.” I told
her it was because I had no desire to be a leader in local politics, and I had
small children, and I just didn’t have the time. Those things were true, but I
also think that the sting of that loss in high school was still there, even all
those years later. I just would not risk that kind of loss again. I was afraid
to put myself out there and get hurt. I was afraid of losing and being
humiliated. I was afraid.
The parable before us today is
another hard one to understand, to read, to hear, and definitely to preach. It
is disturbing for many reasons – the use of the words slave and master, the
harsh and disproportionate punishment at the end are just a couple of reasons
why this parable is disturbing. And while there are a variety of ways to dive
into this strange and harsh parable, one sentence stood out to me – when the
third enslaved man told his master why he buried the talent that he was given,
it was because he was afraid.
Often when we hear this
parable, we hear it as part of a stewardship sermon, as an allegory with God as
the master. God has given us a significant number of talents. Those talents are
for us to use, to put out into the world. We must use them, or we risk
disappointing God, and look what happened to the one who did that.
Yet while we associate talents
with things that we are able to do, special gifts that we have been given, such
as the talent for music, for art, for public speaking, for leadership, for
business, for gardening etc., in this parable a talent refers to a sum
of money. A large sum of money. One talent was equivalent to what a daily wage
earner might make in 15 to 20 years! To say that is a lot of money is an
understatement. One commentator estimated that combined, the master entrusted
his three servants with approximately 1.5 million dollars in today’s money! 1.5
million!
That is a heck of a lot of money,
and it is also a statement of trust on the part of the master. The man entrusts
his servants with these talents, with this extraordinary sum of money. Then he
goes on a long journey, with apparently no hint as to how long he will be gone,
when he might return, or if he will communicate with them while he is away. So,
it is up to these three enslaved men to make the most of the talents with which
they were entrusted while the man is away.
The first two do just that. No
sooner than the first slave had the five talents in hand, he went and traded
them and made five more. The second enslaved man doesn’t waste any time either.
He takes his two talents and trades them making two more. I’m going to assume
here that the first two knew that what they were doing was risky. It is also
quite possible that they could have lost the original talents they were given,
and wound up with nothing, or worse, in debt. But the master entrusted them so
they go for it.
Then we come to our third enslaved
man. Poor guy. I mean that, poor guy. To do what the other two did was to take
a huge risk. And I’m sure that risk felt terrifying. He does not want to go for
it. He just doesn’t want to lose what he has been given. So, he buries the
talent. He doesn’t risk trading. He does not risk investing. He buries the
talent and waits.
After a long time, the man returns.
He goes to his slaves and says, “Okay, it is time to settle accounts. I
entrusted you three with so much. Now what have you done with what I entrusted
you?”
The first enslaved man gives the master
the ten talents that he made from the original five, and the master said,
“Well done! You have been
trustworthy with a few things. I will put you in charge of many things. Enter
into the joy of your master.”
The second enslaved man came forward
and gives the man his four talents, built from the original two. The man’s
response is equally as delighted.
“Well done! Enter into the joy of
your master.”
Then our third enslaved man approaches.
Poor guy. He hands him the one talent, which probably still had dirt clinging
to it from its long time in the ground, and said,
Master, I knew that you were a harsh
man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter
seed; so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here you
have what is yours.”
“Oh, you knew, did you?”
What did this third enslaved man
know, or what did he assume? There is nothing in the text to indicate that the
master was what the slave said he was. There is no secret or hidden word in the
Greek that reveals that but is lost in translation. So, did the slave’s belief
in the man’s harshness rest in something that we are not told, or is it that
the enslaved man was so afraid of messing up and disappointing the master’s
trust, that he acted out of fear. And that fear became a self-fulfilling
prophecy. Not only did his fear cause him to lose his master’s trust, but it
also caused the man to act in a harsh, malevolent way. As I said earlier, the
punishment that the master meted out is way out of proportion to the
transgression. The third enslaved man did not lose the talent. He just didn’t
do anything with it. The master still got back what was his. Yet the third man
was punished harshly anyway.
While I think that fear plays a
large part in this strange parable, I also think that trust plays its part as well.
The master entrusted those enslaved men with an abundance from the start. The
first two servants acted on that trust. They trusted in return. They took what
they were given, and they made more, much more. They acted in faith. They were
willing to risk everything, and their risk was rewarded. But the third servant
was not willing to take that risk. The third servant could not fathom the trust
that was shown in him, and he could not trust in return. He was guided by his
fear, and his fear stymied him. It paralyzed him. He buried instead of
trusting.
He buried instead of trusting
because he was afraid. And yes, the punishment is harsh. There is no way around
that, and I continue to struggle with the disturbing nature of this punishment.
But, just as I stated last week, the stakes at this moment in Jesus’ ministry
have never been higher. I think these parables are getting tougher and tougher to
hear because of where Jesus is headed and what Jesus is facing.
Jesus is just days away from the
cross. He is days away from the betrayal of Judas and the denial of Peter. He
is just days away from standing before Pilate. He is days away from hearing the
crowds which once shouted hosannas at his entering Jerusalem shouting instead,
“Crucify him! Crucify him!”
The stakes have never been higher.
Jesus knows this. He will soon run out of opportunities to teach the disciples
and anyone else who would hear what it means to be disciples, what it means to
have the kingdom of God in their midst. His last lesson for them will rest in
God’s hands.
The punishment is harsh because
Jesus needs those who will hear to really, truly hear. You have been given an
abundance. You have been entrusted with more than you can possibly imagine.
What will you do with that? Will you take on the risky business of discipleship
and dare to take what you have been given and do even more? Or will you let
fear drive you? Will you let fear motivate you to do … nothing? Will you enter
into the joy, the fullness of life with me, with God, or will you be cast out?
Does God cast us out or do we? Maybe
that’s what living in fear does, it causes us to cast ourselves out. We are not
cast out because the enormous foot of God descends from the clouds and kicks us
into darkness. It is our fear that creates the darkness around us. It is our
fear that keeps us in darkness, a darkness that we mistake for light; a
darkness that we mistake for life.
The master did not rejoice at the
amount that the first enslaved people gave him. He rejoiced that they took the
risk to make anything at all. On the surface, the third enslaved man did
nothing wrong. He didn’t steal the talent or keep it for himself or lie to the
master about what he had not done. But he didn’t take the leap of faith. He
didn’t trust the master or himself as much as the master did. He let his fear
lead him. He let his fear create his own darkness.
Don’t you think that Jesus was
afraid? He knew he was facing a terrifying, terrible, tortuous death. He must
have been afraid. If he was fully human, which is what we profess to believe,
then he was afraid. But he loved more than his fear. He trusted God more than
he was afraid of the humans seeking his death. He loved God and he loved his
neighbors more than he was afraid. So, he didn’t stop. He didn’t seek his own
safety. He didn’t try to save his own skin. He loved more than he was afraid.
That’s what we wrestle with when we
wrestle with this parable. That’s what I wrestle with. Do I love more than I am
afraid? Does my fear create my own darkness? I’m not judging us for being
fearful. Fear is real. I know it lives in me. But can we trust God more than we
fear? Can we love our neighbor more than we fear? Can we say, I was afraid but
I loved anyway because I trust that God’s love is bigger than my fear? Because
that is what is true.
God’s
love is bigger than our fear. God’s love is bigger than our fear. God’s love is
bigger than our fear. Thanks be to God.
Let all of God’s children say,
“Alleluia.”
Amen.